The Emotional Rollercoaster Of And Just Like That's First Season

Shawn

3 min read

Post on Aug 17, 2025

4.4

Share

The Emotional Rollercoaster of And Just Like That's First Season: A Look Back at HBO Max's Controversial Revival

And Just Like That… the Sex and the City revival arrived on HBO Max, promising a reunion with beloved characters and a glimpse into their lives decades later. However, what unfolded wasn't just a continuation of familiar storylines; it was an emotional rollercoaster ride that left viewers both captivated and deeply divided. This article dives into the highs and lows of the first season, exploring the controversies, the triumphs, and the lasting impact on fans.

The Shock of Mr. Big's Death: The season's most jarring moment, and arguably the most discussed, was the sudden death of John James "Mr. Big" Preston (Chris Noth). While the show aimed for a realistic portrayal of grief and unexpected loss, the execution sparked intense debate. Many felt the death served as a shocking plot device, while others appreciated its exploration of complex grief and the unpredictable nature of life. This unexpected twist immediately propelled the show into the headlines, generating significant buzz across social media and traditional news outlets. The controversy surrounding Mr. Big's death alone ensured And Just Like That would be a significant cultural conversation.

Navigating New Relationships and Old Friendships: Beyond the Big shock, the season delved into the evolving dynamics of Carrie, Miranda, and Charlotte's relationships. Carrie's journey of rediscovering herself after loss, Miranda's exploration of her sexuality and evolving friendship with Che Diaz, and Charlotte's struggles with her teenage daughter – all provided compelling narratives. However, these storylines weren't without criticism. Many viewers found Che Diaz's character divisive, sparking online discussions and debates about representation and comedic timing. The evolution of Miranda and Steve's relationship also garnered mixed reactions.

A Modern Take on Aging and Identity: And Just Like That attempted to tackle contemporary issues facing women in their 50s, including aging, identity crises, and navigating changing social landscapes. The show’s exploration of these themes resonated with many viewers, prompting meaningful conversations about body image, career transitions, and the complexities of female friendships. This willingness to engage with these often-overlooked aspects of aging women garnered praise from some critics and viewers.

<h3>The Criticism and Controversy: Why the Season Divided Viewers</h3>

While the show garnered a significant viewership, it also faced substantial criticism. Beyond the polarizing Che Diaz character and the handling of Mr. Big's death, the show's perceived lack of consistency with the original series' tone and style bothered some long-time fans. The pace of certain storylines felt rushed to others, leaving some plot points underdeveloped. This disconnect contributed to the mixed reactions from viewers.

<h3>A Legacy Continued, Though Questioned: Looking Ahead</h3>

And Just Like That's first season was undoubtedly a cultural phenomenon, sparking passionate debates and generating significant media attention. Whether you loved it or hated it, the show undeniably ignited conversations about aging, loss, and female friendship in the modern era. The show's second season has been announced, leaving many wondering how the creators will address the criticisms and continue the story in a way that satisfies both long-time fans and new viewers. Only time will tell if the sequel will manage to bridge the divide and create a more cohesive and satisfying narrative.

What are your thoughts on And Just Like That's first season? Share your opinions in the comments below!