Knicks, 76ers Vie For Ben Simmons: Will He Even Play?

Shawn

3 min read

Post on Sep 09, 2025

4.9

Share

Knicks, 76ers Vie for Ben Simmons: Will He Even Play This Season?

The NBA offseason is heating up, and the Ben Simmons saga is far from over. While the Philadelphia 76ers are reportedly still holding out hope for a trade, the New York Knicks have emerged as a serious contender, creating a fascinating battle for the enigmatic All-Star. But the biggest question isn't where Simmons will play, but if he'll play at all this season.

The drama surrounding Simmons has been well-documented. His playoff struggles in 2021, followed by a reported mental health issue and refusal to play for the 76ers, have cast a long shadow over his career. This uncertainty is making potential suitors, including the Knicks, tread cautiously.

The Knicks' Interest: A Gamble with High Stakes?

For the Knicks, acquiring Simmons represents a high-risk, high-reward proposition. They need a playmaker, a defensive anchor, and a star to elevate their game to the next level. Simmons, on paper, fits the bill. His defensive prowess and ability to facilitate the offense could significantly improve their playoff chances. However, his current mental state and reluctance to play remain major concerns.

Adding Simmons would also require significant roster adjustments. The Knicks would likely need to part with some key players and draft picks, impacting their long-term strategy. The front office faces a tough decision: betting on Simmons' potential return to form or pursuing other, more reliable options.

The 76ers' Dilemma: Holding Out or Cutting Losses?

The 76ers, on the other hand, find themselves in a difficult position. Holding onto Simmons, given his refusal to play, disrupts team chemistry and morale. However, trading him at a discounted price would be a significant blow, especially considering the hefty investment they've made in him. They’re hoping to secure a package that reflects his All-Star potential, despite his recent struggles.

Will Simmons Suit Up This Season? The Mental Health Factor

The elephant in the room, of course, is Simmons' mental health. While details remain private, his reported struggles highlight the importance of prioritizing player well-being in professional sports. His return to the court will depend not only on a successful trade but also on his own recovery and readiness to compete at the highest level. Many experts suggest that a supportive environment and a gradual return to the game might be crucial for his rehabilitation. It's a situation that demands patience and understanding, rather than hasty judgments.

Other Potential Landing Spots and the Future of Ben Simmons

While the Knicks and 76ers dominate the conversation, other teams might quietly be interested in acquiring Simmons if the price is right. The situation is fluid, and the next few weeks could bring significant developments.

Conclusion: A Waiting Game

The Ben Simmons saga is a complex narrative intertwining basketball strategy, mental health considerations, and high-stakes negotiations. Whether he suits up this season remains uncertain. The answer will significantly impact not only his career but also the fortunes of the Knicks, the 76ers, and potentially other NBA teams. The coming weeks will be crucial in determining the next chapter of this captivating story. Stay tuned for updates!