And Just Like That's Rollercoaster Ride: A Critical Review Of The Season

Shawn

3 min read

Post on Aug 16, 2025

4.9

Share

And Just Like That's Rollercoaster Ride: A Critical Review of Season Two

And Just Like That… the sequel to the iconic Sex and the City has concluded its second season. Leaving fans breathless, bewildered, and buzzing with debate, the show's latest run has been anything but predictable. This review dives deep into the highs and lows, exploring what worked, what didn't, and ultimately, whether the series deserves another season.

A Season of Ups and Downs: Navigating Complex Themes

Season two of And Just Like That tackled complex themes with varying degrees of success. The exploration of grief, aging, and shifting relationships resonated with many viewers, offering a nuanced portrayal of female friendships in their 50s and beyond. Carrie Bradshaw's journey of self-discovery post-Big's death, while sometimes meandering, felt authentic in its portrayal of the messy process of healing. The introduction of new characters, like the charming and enigmatic comedian, Herbert, added fresh energy to the dynamic.

However, not all storylines landed as smoothly. The character arc of Che Diaz, for instance, continued to draw significant criticism, with many feeling the character lacked depth and felt forced into the narrative. Similarly, some plot points felt rushed or underdeveloped, leaving viewers wanting more. This inconsistency in pacing and character development is a key area where the season fell short.

What Worked Brilliantly:

• The Focus on Female Friendship: The core of Sex and the City's appeal always lay in the complex and evolving friendships of the main characters. And Just Like That successfully maintained this focus, showcasing the unwavering support and occasional friction inherent in long-term relationships.
• Authentic Portrayals of Aging: The show didn't shy away from depicting the realities of aging, from physical changes to the emotional challenges of navigating later life. This honest representation resonated with many viewers who appreciated the show's willingness to tackle these often-ignored aspects of the female experience.
• Exploration of Grief and Healing: Carrie's journey of grief and finding her way back to joy felt authentic and relatable to many viewers who have experienced loss. The show tackled this sensitive subject matter with care and sensitivity.

Areas Needing Improvement:

• Inconsistent Character Development: While some characters shone, others felt underdeveloped or inconsistently written. This unevenness disrupted the overall narrative flow and prevented full viewer engagement.
• Pacing Issues: The season occasionally suffered from pacing problems, with some plot lines feeling rushed, while others dragged on unnecessarily. A more balanced approach would have strengthened the overall narrative.
• Controversial Character Choices: The character of Che Diaz remains a point of contention among viewers, with many expressing frustration with their portrayal and integration into the story.

The Verdict: A Mixed Bag with Potential

And Just Like That season two presents a mixed bag. While it successfully captured the essence of female friendship and offered a nuanced exploration of complex themes, inconsistent character development and pacing issues held it back from reaching its full potential. The series demonstrates a clear understanding of its core audience, successfully navigating the complexities of aging and loss. However, the creative team needs to address the criticisms leveled at certain characters and storylines to ensure future seasons deliver a more consistent and satisfying viewing experience.

Looking Ahead: Will there be a Season 3?

While HBO Max hasn't officially confirmed a third season, the show's dedicated fanbase and cliffhanger ending suggest a renewal is likely. However, substantial improvements in character development and pacing are crucial for the show to recapture its full potential and maintain its dedicated viewership. Only time will tell whether And Just Like That can truly live up to its predecessor's legacy. But for now, the debate continues, making this a show that refuses to be easily categorized. What did you think of Season 2? Share your thoughts in the comments below!